| « home | Browsing all comments (spoilers: on | off) (info: on | off) | next 25 |
 |
<Garygoh884> 'Grab the Dalek' uploaded by Garygoh884. |
 |
<mark> Moved to graveyard: Not needed. |
 |
<mark> 'No mod cons 5' uploaded by mark: Trying to take it away from being a massive ball kicking exercise. |
 |
<xeno> 'No mod cons 4' uploaded by xeno. |
 |
<xeno> Moved to graveyard: Idea didn't work |
 |
<Dave> Anyway, sorry devin, rant over :). Just to avoid a similar mess to last time, do you think could do an alternative mod? It doesn't have to make a puzzle yet... <Dave> Sorry, I don't mean to be harsh, but, to elaborate further. The whole point of restricting the number of mods is to develop a level that has not had a style imposed on by any one player but by an organic development process. When you make a mod within those constraints it will not be complete, but you will always have a preconceived idea for its ultimate usage. The fun bit is watching it interpretted totally differently by somebody else, so by the time you get your hands on it again you are forced to throw your idea out the window and think afresh. <devin> I'm sorry, I never had the chance to view the rules. <Dave> I thought the idea was 10ish changes, but preferrably a maxuimum of 10! Since when did 36 qualify as 10ish? You have effectively had 4 goes in one... <devin> 'No mod cons 3' uploaded by devin: Mod 3; enjoy! |
 |
<Dave> 'No mod cons 2' uploaded by Dave: Something to play with later. |
 |
<mm> 'No mod cons 1' uploaded by mm: 11 tiles, I hope you don't mind, it's just a first try. |
|
|
<mark> Rules 1.add up to 10ish tiles to make it harder 2.removing tiles is permitted but wait a while 3.wait at least 1 player before modding again 4.only thing not to touch is start and finish places.(this could ruin someone's good work) 5.check to see if there is a version out before loading yours. 6.once there are a couple of versions out dating yours delete level. 7.you must solve before modding. 8.please rate levels so we know how many are on board. Ps i have read all the latest comments and kept them in mind,but i stuck with 10ish because it would be a shame if your mod needed a few more than 10 to make it work. <mark> 'No mod cons' uploaded by mark: Ok so here it is a new blank starter,same theme. Rules roughly the same but no bots or bombs. Plenty of scope to think outside the box on this one,who knows where this might go could we make another gem. |
 |
<mm> The concept in general is great! I don't think we need new roules, but we might want to define tighter ones? How about a decreasing amount of changes per mod? Let's say first mod: 10 tiles (maximum), second mod: (max.) 9 tiles... 10th mod: 1 tile. This would automatically limit the amount of mods to 10, and might increase the style rating as well. It's just an idea, but might be worth trying? |
 |
<Dave> I'm wondering how far we can go doing it the old school way without bots or bombs: 'No mod cons'. Annoyingly, I can't look at your solution now, I'm on a different computer, but redundancy did seem a possibility from what I saw of Jim's. Will have a look in the morning. Either way, I'm calling it quits. <mark> Yes Jims solution is same as mine in around about way . Im sure adding original and speedrun you possibly end up with a spare piece. But i also vote calling quits,this level has been fantastic fun. If you want to start again changing the start and finish position should create a new puzzle. Have no clue about facebook, never even spoke one word on the internet until this game. <Dave> Mark, it's human nature to want to make harder each time, and I'm as guilty as anybody else. But the concept has been proven now, so next time... <Dave> Cheers Jim, and nice solution. We currently have 4 levels from this thread left in triage, all considered, I think that is a sensible amount given the combined effort that has been put in. Not sure about the other thread. It's tempting to go back to wowei's mod and take all the other stuff out, but, personally, I feel like a clean slate. Any ideas on the rules? |
 |
<Jim> Moved to graveyard: No longer needed. |
|
|
<Dave> Just checked, it's had one comment in 3 years! Might as well do something useful with it... <Dave> That is a very good point. I think this discussion needs to carry on elsewhere otherwise we will clog up feedback and level comments, as well as the graveyard. Escape facebook page seems to be working... <mark> Yes a new template would be good,i have been thinking about it quite a bit. Your right about the other threads they more levels on ther own. N7DOT'S starter does not leave much space to do anything with . Why i think we are the mods got stuck in a pattern early is no one was adding tiles for creative reasons, just trying to make it harder evry time. If a new template is started we have to add style as well as difficulty when modding. Perhaps the first 3 or 4 mods should add to the background, then start on the puzzle aspect. <Dave> Hi Mark, I suppose it could be made even harder, but I'm not sure it would add any value. I haven't optimised the solution at all, I just uploaded as soon as I cracked it, so I expect it could be shortened considerably. Even so, I think this has to be the limit, any longer and we lose the fun factor. I reckon we give it a couple of days for the dust to settle and then see if anybody else wants to set a new template (N7DOT's one already has a predetermined style). It would be nice if could generate an entirely different type of puzzle. What do you think? |
 |
<mark> Ps i wont delete until you say so. Pps if i had not rated mm's level and left a teaser speed run mm might have been thinking it was really hard. When i knew as a fact 4 or 5 people found it easy. |
| « home | Browsing all comments (spoilers: on | off) (info: on | off) | next 25 |